BOSTON – Ceres urged the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) to withdraw a proposal that would rescind an important federal rule shareholders rely on to prompt meaningful dialogue with companies on a range of financial business issues. Â
The SEC plans to undo Rule 14a-8, the primary means by which shareholders can include written requests in company proxy ballots. Â
In a public comment letter submitted today, Ceres opposed the rescission, arguing that the SEC would undo the primary way investors make their views on material matters known to the corporate boards and management they own stating:Â
“If adopted, it would create extraordinary uncertainty about the path forward for shareholders to influence corporate decision-making (and also for companies that think it important to engage with their shareholders); would make it particularly difficult or impossible for retail or small shareholders to make proposals and for others to vote on those proposals; would greatly impede shareholders’ ability to drive important good-governance and other goals; would inevitably lead to an increase in litigation regarding what can or cannot go into a company’s proxy statement; would prompt investors to take other paths such as “vote no” campaigns or proxy fights; and would have other untoward results.”Â
 Ceres' Key Points:  Â
Proposals act as an early warning system for financial risk. Investors filed 264 proposals asking companies to assess and disclose financial sustainability risks from 2002 through 2024. Companies initially resisted, but over time sustainability reporting became standard practice. By 2025, 94% of S&P 500 companies issued sustainability reports.Â
Proposals drive mainstream governance improvements. In 1999, roughly 40% of S&P 500 companies had boards of directors with annual director elections, which are associated with higher firm value. Â By 2025, 88% of S&P 500 companies had all directors elected annually.Â
Rescission affects all investors. Asset managers, pension funds representing teachers, laborers, public safety officials, and others holding trillions of dollars in assets may never file a proposal. But they rely on proxy votes to protect their beneficiaries. Fewer proposals on the ballot would diminish their voice, and the SEC's economic analysis fails to account for them.Â
The letter also challenges the SEC’s position that it lacks authority to issue Rule 14a-8, a rule that has been in place for more than 80 years, challenges its policy rationales for rescission, and claims that shareholder proposals are a costly and unnecessary burden imposed on public companies.Â
"Shareholder proposals often flag significant financial issues, from those related to extreme weather to transition risk, before they become systemic problems, and they help companies address these issues and strengthen long-term value," said Steven Rothstein, Chief Program Officer at Ceres. "Many of today’s responsible business and governance practices we’ve come to know became mainstream largely because of Rule 14a-8.  Rescinding the rule throws away those benefits with little concrete evidence of harm and will make it difficult or impossible for shareholders to bring requests to companies.” Â
Since the SEC announced its intention to rescind Rule 14a-8, a growing number of bipartisan advocates, institutional investors, and faith-based investors have spoken in support of keeping the longstanding rule in place. In a piece in the Washington Examiner, former Florida Republican Congressman Carlos Curbelo said, “A government that decides which investor voices are legitimate and then removes the mechanism for the others to be heard is not reducing regulation. It is substituting political judgment for market discipline.” Peter Flaherty, Chairman and CEO of the National Legal and Policy Center, wrote in the Wall Street Journal, “Closing the process doesn’t remove politics from markets; it prevents owners from resolving policy disagreements through market mechanisms.Â
In July, Ceres, the U.S. Sustainable Investment Forum, the Interfaith Center on Corporate Responsibility, the Shareholder Rights Group, For the Long Term, and New York State Comptroller Thomas DiNapoli signed a letter petitioning the SEC to pursue a different approach rather than rescinding the rule. Â
About Ceres Â
Ceres is a nonprofit advocacy organization working to accelerate the transition to a cleaner, more just, and resilient economy. With data-driven research and expert analysis, we inspire investors and companies to act on the world's sustainability challenges and advocate for market and policy solutions. Together, our efforts transform industries, unlock new business opportunities, and foster innovation and job growth – proving that sustainability is the bottom line. For more information, visit ceres.org. Â
Â